Captain Gary Carpenter

Captain Gary Carpenter is a seasoned Lake Erie guide with over 20 years of experience navigating the "Walleye Capital of the World." As the owner and lead captain of Sara J Fishing Charters, Gary has dedicated his life to his passion for angling, earning a reputation as one of the most reliable and knowledgeable captains in the Lorain and Cleveland areas.

Known for his "Guaranteed Fish" policy, Captain Gary specializes in tracking the seasonal migrations of Walleye, Yellow Perch, Smallmouth Bass, and Steelhead. His expertise extends beyond just finding the fish; he is a frequent participant in regional fishing seminars and shows, where he shares his deep understanding of Lake Erie’s complex ecosystem and advanced trolling techniques.

Gary operates a fleet of high-performance vessels, including the Sara J II, a spacious 41-foot Sea Hawk powered by twin 450 HP engines. Designed for both serious sportfishing and group comfort, his boats are equipped with top-tier navigational electronics, climate control, and full amenities to ensure a first-class experience for every guest.

Whether he is hosting a family with young children, a corporate outing, or seasoned anglers looking to limit out, Captain Gary’s philosophy remains the same: provide a hands-on, educational, and high-energy day on the water. His commitment to guest satisfaction and his "phenomenally phenomenal" (as described by his regulars) work ethic have made Sara J Fishing Charters a premier destination for anyone looking to experience the best of Lake Erie.

Home Port: Lorain, Ohio

Specialties: Walleye, Perch, Bass, and Steelhead

Vessel: 41' Sea Hawk & 34' King Cat Catamarans